Skip to content
Silent Reads

When the Blacksmith Has a Million Detractors, Then I Am Among Them.

The moment I discovered that Clint from Stardew Valley had been announced as one of the two bachelors in the upcoming 1.7 update, I exclaimed with disbelief, “That incel?!” I was fixated for hours afterward — if Clint has a legion of critics (and he does), count me among their ranks; were he to have no haters, I have left the world of the living. Yet, with some reflection, I’ve come to see that maybe that’s exactly the point — there is no character in greater need of redemption than Clint.

The Source of the Ire

Clint has attracted significant criticism for a long time, largely due to his obsession with Emily, another marriage candidate. During his first heart events, he seeks your advice about how to talk to women, proceeds to act incredibly awkwardly in front of Emily, who is taking his order in the saloon, then laments to the player that he’s “doomed.” He often appears pessimistic, desperate, and somewhat unsettling — to many, he feels like a classic “nice guy” who becomes upset at the smallest perceived rejection.

A Common Reaction

The response to this part of the 1.7 update was far from unique. Players have voiced a host of grievances, sadness about who should've been chosen instead, and endless jokes following the announcement. A commentator wrote, “Imagine getting off a terrible day at work and finding out Clint is now someone you can marry in Stardew Valley.”

A Glimmer of Hope

Nevertheless, part of the conversation on the matter hasn’t been so bleak and — reluctantly — has raised some valid arguments. Some fans have compared the idea of Clint’s redemption to that of Haley. Haley starts as notoriously rude when you first meet her, but warms up as you befriend her, a journey some have called “power-leveling Haley to make her better to be around.” Clint possesses much that same potential, but with one key difference: he makes many gamers the ick.

Image: ConcernedApe

The 'Ick' Factor

I’ve personally always found Haley’s initial unpleasantness easier to stomach than Clint’s one-sided obsession with a woman who isn't interested, and numerous fans seem to feel that sentiment. It's difficult to pinpoint a finger on precisely why — maybe it's simply a situation many fans can relate to, provoking a stronger gut response to Clint. This ick factor inherent to Clint undeniably presents an additional challenge in him being seen as an appealing romantic partner, but that might be just another reason the character desperately needs redemption.

A Trace of Understanding

I will admit that, despite how often I’ve shouted about how much Clint needs to change his ways, he can evoke some level of sympathy. Perhaps not when the infamous bush-hiding incident, but overall, he comes across as a melancholy, isolated man. A fan wrote, “Clint is someone looking for someone who will choose him back, and this is what being romanceable gives him.”

A Role for Redemption

Clint’s new relationship storyline might not appeal to all types of Stardew Valley player, but it serves a purpose. As dubious as I am about ever consider him as spouse material, ConcernedApe is a wonderful writer known for adding layers to all the residents in Pelican Town. Just as with past updates, the new version seems to be a substantial new addition crafted with care at its heart, and Clint’s development is surely not handled carelessly. Perhaps with Clint’s new romance future, players can at last put their hate for him aside and place it to its rightful target — on Pierre.

By

Amy Russell

A passionate literary critic and avid reader with a background in English literature, dedicated to uncovering hidden gems in modern fiction.

Silent Reads

Type to search articles.