Skip to content
Silent Reads

‘A Strategic Error’: How the Reform UK Political Machine Backfired in a Welsh Byelection.

Yuliia Bond manages two jobs, cares for two children, and is studying at university. This past fall, she made time to take on Reform UK when it sought to win the Caerphilly constituency byelection.

Bond, a refugee from Ukraine who has made a home in south Wales, explained she was unable to remain silent as Reform tried to gain the parliamentary seat in the Senedd, the Welsh parliament.

“Members of our Ukrainian community spoke up,” Bond remarked. “We confronted the misinformation because we didn’t want our neighbours from being misled into resenting us. I didn’t want people becoming hostile to us because of lies. So I voiced my concerns and others followed suit.

“Reform UK attempted to generate fear and division with strategies used not only in the UK, but by right-wing political parties across Europe and across the world. The messages they used in Caerphilly didn’t feel local. They felt imported – like someone copied a script from another country and dropped it through our doors.”

An Overconfident Campaign Meets Community Resistance

The party, led by Nigel Farage, was certain it could win the byelection, particularly since Labour, the historically strong party in Wales for a century, appears to be declining rapidly. An energetic campaign by the Welsh nationalists, Plaid Cymru – and individuals such as Bond – kept out the rightwing party.

“Their greatest mistake was presuming that people here have no independent thought,” Bond said. “They thought nobody would check the facts. They assumed that refugees are not just in need, but somehow uninformed. That is incorrect. We may have fled a war, but we are not naive. We understand policies.”

One of Reform’s central claims was that the Welsh government’s nation of sanctuary scheme showed both it and Plaid supported a “large-scale immigration agenda” and that “those seeking asylum” were receiving “preferential treatment”. This assertion was unfounded – more than 80% of the sanctuary funds had been spent on supporting Ukrainian refugees.

Bond commented: “When I saw the campaign literature, all I could see was a clear attempt to divide people, to blame a small group, and increase hostility in a place that had been welcoming to us.

“It failed in Caerphilly because the Ukrainian community and refugees from different backgrounds are not outsiders. We are integrated into the community. People are familiar with us.

“They see us at schools, in shops, at work, volunteering. They know what we add. The portrayal in the leaflet simply contradicted reality. Most residents could feel that something was off. It felt like deception, not truth.”

The Aftermath and Lasting Lessons

Bond was interviewed in the “gratitude orchard” in Caerphilly, established by members of the Ukrainian community as a token of appreciation for the kind reception they have received.

She said the arrival of Reform had put pressure on Ukrainian people in the area. “Vulnerable people should not have to carry this weight. Yet, during the election, we had to raise our voices first. Only later did support come – from local residents, politicians from different parties, and local media.”

There are scheduled Senedd elections in May when Reform hopes to become the leading party in Wales.

Bond said people opposing Reform in Wales in May and in other elections across the UK must challenge the party’s messages quickly and with certainty.

“As a Ukrainian, I know how dangerous disinformation can be. The war in Ukraine did not start with weapons. It started with disinformation, propaganda and lies that prepared the ground for violence.
“Disinformation must be countered early, strongly and unambiguously, because hate travels faster than facts. The two months of that byelection were genuinely exhausting. We just had to get through it. But we endured together, and that is why the hate campaign was unsuccessful in Caerphilly.”

The Winning Campaign’s Perspective

For Lindsay Whittle, the victorious Plaid candidate, the period following the byelection was a blur. Public recognition was widespread.

Whittle said both Reform campaigners and their opponents had believed the party might win decisively. She said: “The thought was that they’d spend obscene amounts of money and defeat us.”

So how did they stop the political force? One reason, Whittle thinks, is that Plaid ran an upbeat, positive campaign. “Don’t attack anyone personally because people don’t like that. Keep the message positive. Try and bring together people.

“People in Caerphilly have friends of different nationalities and they don’t like people threatening their friends. Voters understand that without certain people coming to this country, you’re not going to have an NHS or social care. I think Reform misjudged the people of Caerphilly.”

While Whittle made the headlines, an fierce grassroots campaign was taking place in the background. Dedicated party members knocked on thousands of doors.

“We think it was the crucial byelection we’ve ever contested,” one campaigner said. The victory was attributed to strong policies – and people who believe in them passionately.

Community Observations and Academic Analysis

A local editor was surprised at how polarising the campaign was. “We had communities turning on each other, campaign posters removed, really sharp debates online. I was raised in this area and I know everyone’s lovely so to see that side come out was a surprise.”

The turning point is believed to have been a televised debate when an audience member challenged the Reform candidate, stating that people with family members not born in the UK did not feel welcome since Reform had arrived.

“That was someone from our community who had a mixed race family explicitly stating the impact all this language had,” the editor said. “Caerphilly may not be the most multicultural of places but we’ve always welcomed people from overseas. That was the turning point.”

A politics lecturer and native of the area provided a unique perspective on the byelection.

He said Plaid was extremely successful in presenting the election as a straight two-horse race – but this will be harder at the Senedd elections in May when a new representational system is introduced.

“It tended to be somewhat ill-informed or, at times, patronising. But Caerphilly isn’t some post-industrial wasteland uncritically accepting whatever political winds blow from England – it has its own political traditions and, like Wales more broadly, it has its own character and can’t simply be read through the lens of what is happening in England. It was gratifying to see my home town confound those simplistic assumptions.”
By

Amy Russell

A passionate literary critic and avid reader with a background in English literature, dedicated to uncovering hidden gems in modern fiction.

Silent Reads

Type to search articles.